Are your different sheets built from different data sources? Because when I test that I think it works. You could duplicate your data source to create two data sources.
No, they are currently built from one datasource. Are there any impacts to duplicating the data source? Do I just set the relationship up on the Unique Identifier? When I tried to make a copy just now, it caused the numbers on the dashboard to increase dramatically. Is there not a way to do it without duplicating datasource?